%20(2).png)
- Harry Bloom
- Dec 2, 2025
- 4 min read
By Dr. Harry Bloom, Founder and President, Benchmarking for Good, Inc.
Every head of school has faced this moment: a valued teacher resigns, and in the exit conversation, compensation comes up. The instinct is to assume salary is the most important problem. But what if that instinct is wrong?
Benchmarking for Good analyzed staff climate survey data from nearly 1,600 faculty and staff members across 25 diverse Jewish day schools to answer a simple question: What actually drives job satisfaction and the willingness to recommend your school as a place to work?
The findings challenge conventional wisdom—and point toward interventions that are both more effective and more within a school leader's control.
The Surprising Truth About Salary
Let's address the elephant in the room first. Salary satisfaction showed the weakest correlation with both job enjoyment (r=0.30) and likelihood to recommend the school as an employer (r=0.27).
To put that in perspective: salary explains only about 9% of why teachers enjoy their jobs. The other 91% is driven by factors that have nothing to do with the paycheck.
This doesn't mean compensation is irrelevant. Teachers need to be paid fairly, and chronic underpayment creates real hardship–and keeps qualified teachers from applying. But the data suggests that once you're in a reasonable range, incremental salary increases yield diminishing returns on satisfaction. A school paying at the 50th percentile with an excellent work environment will likely have happier teachers than a school paying at the 75th percentile with a toxic culture.
What Actually Matters: The Top Three Drivers
1. Work Environment (r=0.61)
The single strongest predictor of job satisfaction is how teachers feel about their overall work environment—the totality of conditions surrounding their work, including collegiality, supervision, support, and physical space.
This factor alone explains 37% of the variance in job satisfaction. That's four times more predictive power than salary.
What this means for leaders: Walk your hallways with fresh eyes. Do your faculty members have each others’ backs? Is the faculty lounge a place people want to gather, or a forgotten closet with a broken coffee maker? Do teachers have adequate and available technology to do their jobs? Is praise for hard working faculty a norm or a rarity? These "small" environmental factors compound into a daily experience that shapes how people feel about coming to work.
2. Pride in School (r=0.58)
The second strongest driver is whether staff feel proud to be part of your institution. This factor is particularly powerful for predicting whether teachers will recommend your school to others—it's actually the #1 driver of recommendations.
What this means for leaders: Pride isn't manufactured through slogans or swag. It emerges when people believe they're part of something meaningful and excellent. Celebrate genuine accomplishments. Share student success stories and positive parent and alumni survey results. Connect daily work to mission. When a teacher helps a struggling student break through, make sure that story gets told.
3. Career Growth Opportunities (r=0.51)
Here's where the data reveals something actionable that many schools overlook. Career growth opportunities showed a uniquely strong relationship with job satisfaction—significantly stronger than its relationship with recommendations (a statistically significant difference of p=0.002).
In other words: teachers who see a future for themselves at your school are much more likely to enjoy their current jobs. Those who feel stuck are at risk, even if they like other aspects of their work.
What this means for leaders: Day schools often struggle here because hierarchies are flat. You can't promote everyone to department chair. But career growth isn't only about titles. Consider: curriculum leadership roles, mentorship responsibilities, conference presentation opportunities, action research projects, cross-divisional committees, or tuition toward advanced degrees. The question every teacher should be able to answer is: "How will I be better at my craft two years from now than I am today?"
The Supervisor Effect
Four supervisor-related factors also showed strong correlations with satisfaction:
Supervisor appreciation for efforts (r=0.45)
Feedback that promotes professional growth (r=0.44)
Realistic workload expectations (r=0.41)
Support when dealing with difficult parents (r=0.37)
A teacher's direct supervisor shapes their daily experience more than almost any school-wide policy.
What this means for leaders: Invest heavily in developing your supervisors. The assistant principal who thinks "management" means distributing memos and collecting lesson plans is actively harming retention. Train supervisors to give meaningful feedback, express genuine appreciation, and shield their teams from unreasonable demands. Consider 360-degree feedback processes that surface supervisory problems before they drive departures.
Putting It Into Practice
Based on this analysis, here's a prioritized action framework:
High Impact, Often Overlooked
Audit your physical work environment for friction points
Create meaningful career pathways beyond traditional promotions
Train supervisors in appreciation, feedback, and advocacy
High Impact, Commonly Recognized
Cultivate genuine pride through mission connection,survey data showing impact, and storytelling
Foster open communication channels where concerns are heard
Ensure teachers have adequate tools and resources
Important but Not Sufficient
Maintain competitive (not necessarily top-of-market) compensation
Address salary compression and equity issues
Monitor for Systemic Issues
Staff-parent interaction quality
Staff-student interaction quality
Colleague collaboration and culture
The Bottom Line
School leaders often feel trapped by budget constraints when thinking about teacher satisfaction. This data offers a liberating reframe: the most powerful levers aren't primarily financial.
A teacher who feels proud of their school, works in a supportive environment, sees a path for growth, and has a supervisor who appreciates them and has their back—that teacher is far more likely to love their job than one who simply receives a larger paycheck in a dysfunctional environment.
The work of building that kind of workplace is harder than writing bigger checks. It requires attention to culture, investment in leadership development, and a willingness to address environmental factors that might seem mundane. But the payoff—in retention, in morale, in the quality of education your students receive—is substantial.
Your teachers are telling you what they need. The question is whether you're listening.
How Benchmarking for Good Can Help
We provide schools with access to proven research tools that can tell you what your faculty value and how satisfied they are with all key aspects of job satisfaction and advocacy–giving you the facts you may not have currently, but need to excel at your job as a school leader.
Contact Dr. Harry Bloom at harrybloom@benchmarkingforgood.org to learn more about how to access these research services.
